- Open Access
Exploring the rice dispensable genome using a metagenome-like assembly strategy
Genome Biology volume 16, Article number: 187 (2015)
The dispensable genome of a species, consisting of the dispensable sequences present only in a subset of individuals, is believed to play important roles in phenotypic variation and genome evolution. However, construction of the dispensable genome is costly and labor-intensive at present, and so the influence of the dispensable genome in genetic and functional genomic studies has not been fully explored.
We construct the dispensable genome of rice through a metagenome-like de novo assembly strategy based on low-coverage (1–3×) sequencing data of 1483 cultivated rice (Oryza sativa L.) accessions. Thousands of protein-coding genes are successfully assembled, including most of the known agronomically important genes absent from the Nipponbare rice reference genome. We develop an integration approach based on alignment and linkage disequilibrium, which is able to assign genomic positions relative to the reference genome for more than 78.2 % of the dispensable sequences. We carry out association mapping studies for rice grain width and 840 metabolic traits using 0.46 million polymorphisms between the dispensable sequences of different rice accessions. About 23.5 % of metabolic traits have more significant association signals with polymorphisms from dispensable sequences than with SNPs from the reference genome, and 41.6 % of trait-associated SNPs have concordant genomic locations with associated dispensable sequences.
Our results suggest the feasibility of building a species’ dispensable genome using low-coverage population sequencing data. The constructed sequences will be helpful for understanding the rice dispensable genome and are complementary to the reference genome for identifying candidate genes associated with phenotypic variation.
The pan-genome concept refers to the non-redundant collection of all DNA sequences present in the entire population of a species [1, 2], which comprises a “core genome” containing sequences present in all individuals, a “dispensable genome” containing sequences present in two or more individuals , and unique sequences specific to an individual . Previous studies showed the existence of individual-specific and population-specific DNA sequences in different organisms [1, 5]. Traditional studies tended to use several finished genome sequences to discover dispensable sequences and build a species’ pan-genome [6, 7]. However, decoding the complete genome of plants or animals is still labor-intensive and costly at present. Alternatively, a recent study characterized the maize pan-transcriptome using sequencing of RNAs from different maize inbred lines . They obtained tens of thousands of dispensable sequences by assembling sequencing data for each line separately. However, such a method could not discover genes expressed at low levels or in specific tissues and the obtained sequences were usually very short .
With the application of next-generation sequencing, huge amounts of low-coverage population sequencing data have been generated [8, 9]. These data were usually generated for genome-wide association studies (GWASs) and population genomic studies, which mainly focused on the single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) or insertions or deletions (INDELs) in reference genomic regions [8, 10]. A large portion of individual- and subpopulation-specific sequences were left out and present studies have not taken full advantage of the huge amount of population sequencing data.
Rice (Oryza sativa L.) is a staple food crop and an ideal model for functional genomic research of monocots. The availability of the high quality Nipponbare rice reference genome sequence has greatly accelerated gene cloning ; over 600 genes were cloned by the end of 2010 . However, a lot of genes controlling important traits have been found to be absent from the Nipponbare reference genome , such as GW5 , Sub1A , and Pikm-1 . This indicates that one genome is insufficient . More genome sequences are needed to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the pan-genome of rice.
The absence of important genes from the rice reference genome, and the availability of population resequencing data [8, 9], prompted us to develop methods to identify the sequences that were absent from the reference genome by de novo assembly of population sequencing data. These sequences are important components of the rice dispensable genome.
In this study, we show the feasibility of using only the population sequencing data with each sample sequenced at very low coverage (1–3×) to identify the DNA sequences present in some or all of these cultivated rice accessions but absent from the Nipponbare reference genome. A metagenome-like assembly strategy was adopted to assemble the reads of various rice accessions to build the sequence map of the rice dispensable genome. We further demonstrate that these sequences would be helpful for understanding the rice dispensable genome and picking candidate genes in quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping and GWASs in rice. The assembled sequences and other information have been deposited in the Panrice database . Users may query this database using accession number or DNA/protein sequence.
Collecting sequence data and assembling the dispensable genome using a metagenome-like assembly strategy
We collected data of 533 rice accessions sequenced at ~2.5× coverage and 950 rice accessions sequenced at ~1× coverage (based on a 384-Mb genome size of the Nipponbare reference genome; Additional file 1) [8, 9, 17–19]. The two data sets consist of low-coverage sequencing data of 1483 cultivated rice accessions from 73 countries, comprising 11.3 billion reads. These reads were mapped to the Nipponbare genome (release 6.1 of the Michigan State University (MSU) Rice Genome Annotation Project) using BWA , providing ~2400-fold coverage of the genome. The details of the mapping rate of each accession are listed in Additional file 2. Cultivated rice comprises two major subspecies, known as the indica and japonica subspecies. The indica subspecies contains indica and aus subgroups and the japonica subspecies contains temperate japonica and tropical japonica subgroups (Figure S1a in Additional file 3) . We classified these 1483 accessions into four divergent groups, corresponding to the four subgroups of cultivated rice, based on principal component analysis using SNPs (“Materials and methods”). The mapping rates of the indica accessions were much lower than those of the japonica accessions (Figure S1b in Additional file 3), mainly because the Nipponbare reference accession is a japonica rice cultivar. This result indicated that a lot of dispensable sequences were present in some rice accessions but absent from the Nipponbare reference accession.
We proposed an assembly strategy incorporating SOAPdenovo , Meta-IDBA , and GICL  to assemble the dispensable sequences (“Materials and methods”; Fig. 1a). Both reads of a read pair of which at least one read could not be mapped to the reference genome were extracted to do de novo assembly (“Materials and methods”). In total, 395,891,829 read pairs (7.0 % of all the read pairs) were collected, of which 628,163,124 reads (79.3 %) could not be mapped to the Nipponbare genome (release 6.1 of the MSU Rice Genome Annotation Project). Due to the substantial genomic differences between the indica and japonica subspecies, independent assembly was carried out using reads of accessions belonging to the two subspecies respectively. The reads of all indica accessions were assembled using SOAPdenovo and Meta-IDBA independently. The scaffolds generated by SOAPdenovo and the contigs produced by Meta-IDBA for the indica subspecies were further clustered and then assembled using GICL. The reads of the japonica accessions were assembled using the same strategy. Contig N50 of the assembly of both subspecies was greatly improved using GICL compared with the assembly results of SOAPdenovo and Meta-IDBA (Fig. 1b). Contig N50 of the final assembly of the indica subspecies was 2344 bp, which was close to the average length of non-transposon loci of the rice Nipponbare reference genome (2853 bp) . The final assembly of the indica subspecies, after the removal of contaminations (“Materials and methods”), contained 52,976 sequences with an average length of 1677 bp (ranging from 500 bp to 26,940 bp) while the assembly of the japonica group was composed of 30,349 sequences with an average length of 1877 bp (ranging from 500–28,300 bp) (Fig. 1c). These two assemblies represent the indica dispensable genome and the japonica dispensable genome, respectively. Only a total of 6397 sequences (12.1 %) of the indica dispensable genome and 3315 sequences (10.9 %) of the japonica dispensable genome were aligned to the Nipponbare genome (release 6.1 of the MSU Rice Genome Annotation Project) with ≥85 % coverage and ≥85 % identity.
We evaluated this assembly strategy by investigating k-mer distributions in reads used to build the dispensable genome and in the final assembly. A k-mer length of 19 was chosen to guarantee that the majority of k-mers were unique while keeping computing resource requirements relatively low. About 90.9 %, 85.2 %, and 86.4 % of all 19-mers of the Nipponbare reference genome and the indica and japonica dispensable genomes, respectively, were unique according to results from Jellyfish . A total of 2.97 billion 19-mers were detected in reads used to build the indica dispensable genome, 71.9 % of which were observed only once (Fig. 2a). We did not observe any peak in the distribution of 19-mers, which was quite distinct from that of deep sequencing reads of a single accession. The frequency of 19-mers decreased, along with an increase in depth, in both the sequencing reads and the cleaned reads (Fig. 2a). The depth of 91.0 % of all 19-mers was smaller than half of the average k-mer depth of all 19-mers (7.05×). This is probably due to the high heterozygosity in the reads used to assemble the dispensable genome as we mixed reads of hundreds of accessions to perform the assembly. In all, 66,135,176 19-mers were detected in the indica assembly (Fig. 2a). The proportion of 19-mers present in the final assembly increased along with the increasing 19-mer depth of all the sequencing reads (Fig. 2b); however, the rate of increase slowed as the depth increased. Only 0.04 % of the 19-mers observed once in the sequencing reads were present in the indica assembly while more than 30.0 % of the 19-mers with a depth greater than 100 were in the assembly (Fig. 2b). To reduce the influence of different sequencing depth among accessions, we did additional analysis based on 353 indica accessions out of the 533 rice accessions with similar sequencing depth of ~2.5× (Additional file 1). We observed that 19-mers present in the sequencing reads of more accessions were more frequently found in the final assembly (Fig. 2c), as about 0.1 % of the 19-mers present in only one accession and 34.1 % of the 19-mers present in 100 accessions were found in the final assembly, respectively.
We further sampled randomly from the 353 indica accessions and investigated the distribution of 19-mers in the sequencing reads of the sampled accessions. To minimize the interference of sequencing error, we only analyzed k-mers with depth ≥2 in the sampled reads, the number of which continuously increased along with the increase in the number of accessions (Fig. 2d). However, the increment rate of the distinct k-mer number was lower than that of the number of sampled accessions, as the number of distinct k-mers with depth ≥2 was shown to scale with the square root of the number of sampled accessions (as revealed by regression modeling; R 2 = 0.998, P = 1.78 × 10−14, Fig. 2d). We also generated assemblies using sequencing reads of randomly selected accessions using the same assembly strategy to build the dispensable genomes. The number of 19-mers of the indica dispensable genome was recovered cumulatively by the assembly with an increasing number of accessions (Fig. 2e). The number of contigs and the total length of the assembly also increased with increasing number of accessions used (Fig. 2f). The 19-mer distribution of the sequencing reads of the japonica accessions was similar to that of the indica accessions with only little difference (Figure S2a–c in Additional file 3). About 0.09 % of 19-mers observed only once while more than 41.9 % of 19-mers observed ≥100 times in the sequencing reads were present in the japonica assembly (Figure S2b in Additional file 3). About 83.5 % of all the 19-mers were observed with depth smaller than half of the average depth of all 19-mers (2.85×), a proportion smaller than that of all the indica reads. Since the genome diversity of indica accessions is higher than that of japonica accessions , these observations indicate that low sequence diversity was beneficial to the assembly of population sequencing data. Taken together, these results demonstrate the feasibility of constructing the rice dispensable genome based on assembly of population sequencing data and provide helpful information for experimental design of future studies on population sequencing data assembly.
Evaluation of the assembly results
To evaluate the quality of the assembly results, all the contigs were aligned to five sequenced genomes of the Oryza genus — Oryza sativa L. ssp. japonica (Nipponbare), Oryza sativa L. ssp. indica (93-11) , Oryza glaberrima (African cultivated rice) , Oryza brachyantha (African wild rice) , and Oryza rufipogon (W1943, Asian wild rice)  — using Blastn (with parameter “-F F”). A total of 30,440 (57.5 %) contigs of the indica dispensable genome were aligned to the other four sequenced Oryza genomes with improved match length (≥100 bp longer) compared with the alignment to the Nipponbare genome (Fig. 3a; Additional file 4). Although the remaining 22,536 contigs (42.5 %) were not aligned to the other four Oryza genomes with remarkable improved match length, 17,956 (79.7 %) of them were aligned with higher alignment scores and 11,378 (63.4 %) of them were aligned with improved identity (≥1 % higher) to the other sequenced Oryza genomes compared with the alignment to the Nipponbare genome (Figure S3 in Additional file 3). Using a more stringent rule, 8932 (16.8 %) contigs were aligned to the other four sequenced Oryza genomes with improved match length (≥90 % of the length of the contig) compared with the alignment to the Nipponbare genome (≤50 % of the length of the contig).
To further evaluate the assembly results, 43 pairs of PCR primers were designed to amplify DNA fragments from the 30 randomly selected contigs (Additional file 5). All of the 43 fragments were amplified with expected sizes using genomic DNA of the corresponding rice accessions which were predicted to contain the sequences, while none could be amplified using genomic DNA of Nipponbare (Fig. 3b; Figure S4 in Additional file 3).
To examine whether the assembly can successfully construct the sequences of genes reported to be absent from the Nipponbare genome, we collected ten such genes from the published literature (Table 1), all of which were related to important traits, including grain size (GW5 [13, 30]), disease resistance (Pikm1-TS , Pikm2-TS , Pib , and Xa27 ), water logging resistance (SNORKEL1, SNORKEL2 , and Sub1A ), salt tolerance (OsHKT2 ), and phosphorus-deficiency tolerance (PSTOL1 ). The sequences of these genes were aligned to the dispensable genomes using Blastn and most of these genes were successfully constructed in the dispensable genomes (Table 1), except SNORKEL1 and SNORKEL2, which are found uniquely in deepwater rice not included in the accessions we used to build the dispensable genomes, and Pib (longer than 10 kb), only a portion of which was assembled.
PSTOL1 was identified in the traditional aus-type rice variety Kasalath . The genomic region of Kasalath harboring PSTOL1 differs greatly from that of Nipponbare. The sequences of Kasalath in this region were decoded in a previous study . We found that many (48.7 %) genes predicted in this region were present in the assembled result of the indica or the japonica dispensable genome (Additional file 6).
Previous studies reported that full-length cDNA sequences of 15 O. rufipogon-specific genes could not be mapped to either the Nipponbare or 93-11 genome [37, 38], and that five of these genes were up- or down-regulated in wounding and/or submergence conditions. We found that 9 of these 15 genes were present in the indica or japonica dispensable genome (Blastn, query coverage ≥80 %, identity ≥90 %; Additional file 7; Figure 3c).
The redundancy between the indica and the japonica dispensable genomes was evaluated by aligning the japonica dispensable genome to the indica dispensable genome using Blastn: 18,033 contigs (34 %) of the indica dispensable genome had alignment hits to the japonica dispensable genome (identity ≥90 %, match length ≥60 % of the length of the indica contig) and 16,426 contigs (54 %) of the japonica dispensable genome had alignment hits to the indica dispensable genome (identity ≥90 %, match length ≥60 % of the length of the japonica contig). In total, 7820 contigs of the indica dispensable genome corresponding to 7689 contigs of the japonica dispensable genome (a total of 8209 pairs) were found to have reciprocal coordinate overlap of more than 60 % (identity ≥90 %). These results suggest that most of the sequences of the dispensable genome are subspecies-specific and subject to rapid gain and loss.
Annotation of protein-coding genes and transposable elements in the dispensable genomes
We utilized an annotation pipeline incorporating Fgenesh , AUGUSTUS , GeneWise , PASA  and EvidenceModeler  to predict protein-coding genes in the dispensable genomes. For the indica dispensable genome, 8991 protein-coding genes were predicted, 1913 of which with strong evidence of expression or homology were tagged as high confidence genes (“Materials and methods”). For the japonica dispensable genome, 6366 protein-coding genes were predicted, of which 1120 were tagged as high confidence genes.
About 186 predicted proteins of the indica dispensable genome were homologous to cloned genes, including disease- or stress-resistance genes (Blastp, E-value < 1e-10; Additional file 8) [12, 44], such as the Brown planthopper resistance gene Bph14, the blast resistance gene Pid3 and the starch branching enzyme IIb gene BEIIb  (Figure S5 in Additional file 3). These genes may provide important candidates for future crop improvements.
Among seven genes reported missing from the reference genome, the structures of the two rice blast resistance genes Pikm1-TS and Pikm2-TS were accurately annotated. Genes Sub1A and OsHKT2 were correctly identified but the predicted structures were inconsistent with those in previous reports [14, 34].
Protein domains and families coded by these 1913 high confidence genes were annotated using Pfam . More than 45 % of these genes are members of gene families (Additional file 9). Besides transposon-related domains, leucine-rich repeat (LRR), NB-ARC domain, zinc finger transcription factors, the stress-antifung family, and protein kinase family proteins were found significantly enriched in the dispensable genome compared with those in the reference genome (Fisher’s exact test, P ≤ 1 × 10−4; Fig. 4a). Of the 1913 predicted genes, 1489 were found to be expressed [reads/per kilobase merged exonic region/per million mapped reads (RPKM) ≥4] using RNA-seq data of ten rice varieties/tissues (Fig. 4b; Additional file 10).
Transposons were reported to play important roles in genome evolution . For the indica dispensable genome, 23,644 transposons were found in 15,542 contigs (29.3 % of all the contigs; Additional file 11). These transposons were categorized into three major classes, retrotransposons, DNA transposons and miniature inverted-repeat transposable elements (MITEs), and different subclasses based on the classification methods used by the Plant Repeat Databases at MSU  (Figure S6 and S7 in Additional file 3). The transposon compositions of the indica and the japonica dispensable genomes exhibited only slight differences (Figure S6 and S7 in Additional file 3; Additional file 11). Most of the annotated transposons were DNA transposons and MITEs. The majority of DNA transposons were harbinger-like elements, a member of which was reported to have retained its biological activity in the coelacanth genome . Most of the MITEs belong to the Stowaway group, which were found to be active in some plant genomes [50, 51].
Determining genomic positions of dispensable sequences relative to the Nipponbare reference genome
In studies of QTL mapping and association mapping, causal genes were usually mapped to a narrow genomic region in which candidates were picked up by the researchers based on gene annotation of the reference genome. In cases where the causal gene does not exist in the reference genome, however, such attempts would be futile. Thus, determining genomic positions of dispensable sequences relative to the Nipponbare reference genome would be helpful for picking candidates for future QTL mapping and association mapping studies in rice, as these provide additional possible candidates.
Since the reads used to construct contigs of the dispensable genome contained hanging read pairs (of which only one read could be reliably aligned to the Nipponbare reference genome), many contigs contained a portion of sequences which could be found in the reference genome. To obtain the genomic position of the contig relative to the Nipponbare genome, each contig was aligned to the Nipponbare reference genome and hits with the top three highest scores were retained (Fig. 5a). However, this was not suitable for contigs with repetitive sequences.
As a result, a linkage disequilibrium (LD)-based approach was applied to identify chromosome positions of the reference genome that were most tightly linked with each contig. The determined chromosome position was considered as the approximate genomic position of this contig relative to the Nipponbare genome. All the 11.3 billion paired-end reads of the 1483 rice accessions were mapped to the dispensable genome using BWA (version 0.6.1) and then SNPs were called using SAMtools (version 0.1.17) [20, 52]. Genotypes of all the rice accessions were obtained at 280,000 evenly distributed SNP sites from RiceVarMap [18, 53], a genomic variation database constructed based on the same set of sequencing data used in this study. The LD (r 2) between a specific SNP on a contig and all the 280,000 SNPs were calculated and the chromosome location of the SNP in the Nipponbare genome with the highest LD was regarded as the chromosome location of this contig determined by this specific SNP (Fig. 5b, c). Each SNP in a contig determined a chromosome location most tightly linked with this contig. The frequency of each chromosome location of a contig was calculated by measuring each location in a 100-kb unit. The two chromosome locations with the highest frequency and the second highest frequency were recorded.
The results from the alignment and LD-based approaches were integrated to obtain the genomic position of each contig relative to the Nipponbare reference genome (Additional file 12). For contigs with results from just a single approach, the best placement was taken as the final location only if it was overwhelmingly superior to the second best placement (Additional file 12). For contigs with locations reported by both approaches within 1 Mb of each other, the result based on the alignment was considered as the final location (Additional file 12). For contigs for which the two approaches gave conflicting results, we adopted the results of the LD-based approach only if it met the set criteria (Additional file 12). For the indica dispensable genome, 33,056 (62.4 %) contigs were assigned genomic positions with consistent results between the two approaches, the two approaches gave conflicting results for 3749 (7.1 %), 3975 (7.5 %) contigs were assigned genomic positions by the LD-based approach alone, and 657 (1.2 %) contigs were assigned genomic positions based solely on the alignment results. The positions of the remaining 11,539 (21.8 %) contigs failed to be assigned.
All of the genes that were reported to be absent from the reference genome and constructed in the dispensable genome were assigned correct genomic positions (“Materials and methods”) relative to the Nipponbare reference genome except for Sub1A (Table 2). We further dissected the reason why Sub1A could not be assigned a genomic position. Few SNPs between different accessions were identified in the contig harboring Sub1A. The frequency for the most tightly linked chromosome location was not overwhelming when compared with the frequency for the second tightly linked chromosome location (2 to 1). What is more, Sub1A contains a short repetitive sequence (930 bp) that can be aligned to multiple chromosome locations. Nevertheless, the most tightly linked chromosome location determined by the LD-based approach was only 130 kb away from the actual location of Sub1A relative to the reported location in the Nipponbare genome. This demonstrates the efficiency of this approach to determine the genomic positions of sequence insertions in the reference genome. The two most tightly linked chromosome locations and the two best alignment results for each contig in the indica dispensable genome are shown in Additional file 13.
The chromosome distributions of contigs of the indica and japonica dispensable genomes were quite similar (Fig. 6). The sequence of each contig of the indica dispensable genome was aligned to all the contigs of the japonica dispensable genome that were located within 50 kb of the indica contig. The sequences of most of these indica–japonica contig pairs were quite distinct (Figure S8 in Additional file 3), implying that the similarity between the chromosome distributions of the indica and japonica dispensable genomes was not caused by the sequence similarity between the indica and japonica contigs located in nearby regions. Of the 8209 indica–japonica contig pairs which were found to have reciprocal coordinate overlap of more than 60 % (identity ≥90 %), both contigs of 6316 contig pairs were assigned genomic positions and the positions of the two contigs for 5279 contig pairs were within 100 kb of each other (Additional file 14).
We further inspected the chromosome distribution of potential insertions to the Nipponbare genome by examining the locations of all the hanging read pairs. The chromosome distribution of contigs was in accordance with the distribution of these potential insertions in general (Fig. 6). Hanging read pairs were found to be enriched around the centromeres of nine chromosomes and the telomeres of two chromosomes (Fig. 6). This may be caused by sequence gaps in the regions of the reference genome. Several chromosome locations that were neither centromeres nor telomeres were also found enriched with hanging read pairs. Although large numbers of hanging read pairs were found in dozens of genomic regions with high repeat density, hotspots of hanging read pairs were not necessary in genomic regions with high repeat density (Fig. 6). As a result, 833 chromosome insertion hotspots were identified based on the chromosome distribution of hanging read pairs and that of contigs of the dispensable genome (Additional files 12 and 15).
Local de novo reassembly for each contig of the dispensable genome
We observed that the raw contigs of the assembly were not quite accurate as a result of sequence heterozygosity introduced by mixing of the reads of multiple accessions. Although the sequence of Sub1A was successfully constructed, five SNPs were detected between the assembled sequence and the reported sequences of different haplotypes of Sub1A. In order to obtain an accurate assembly result for each haplotype, a haplotype-based de novo assembly strategy proposed by Huang et al.  was adopted with slight modification to perform local assembly for each contig (“Materials and methods”).
To evaluate the effects of this local assembly strategy, 1000 genomic regions with an average length of 5322 bp (ranging from 503 bp to 9994 bp) were randomly selected and the read pairs of all the 1483 accessions mapped to these regions were extracted and grouped by local SNPs to perform local reassemblies. For each region, the longest assembly was chosen as the best assembly. The match length between the best assembly result and the original region was used to evaluate the assembly performance. For more than 58 % of these regions, the match length between the best reassembly and the original region was larger than 70 % of the length of the original region. Most of the regions (243 regions, 24.3 %) with poor reassembly results were found to be in the repeat regions of the genome (Figure S9a, c in Additional file 3), which had multiple Blastn alignment to the reference genome (query coverage ≥30 %, identity ≥80 %), while most regions (756, 75.6 %) with good reassembly results were located in unique genomic regions (Figure S9e, g in Additional file 3). A few regions (27, 2.7 %) located in unique genomic regions were poorly assembled because they were relatively long and the reads used to build the best assembly were obtained from relatively more accessions (Figure S9i–l in Additional file 3). In contrast, some regions (61 regions, 6.1 %) in the repeat part of the genome were well reassembled because they were relatively short and the reads used to build the best assembly were obtained from relatively fewer accessions (Figure S9m–p in Additional file 3).
Using this strategy, the sequences of at least one haplotype of GW5, Sub1A, Xa27, and PSTOL1 reported in previous studies [14, 30, 32] were accurately built (Table 1; Figure S10 in Additional file 3). The local de novo assembly results for Pikm1-TS, Pikm2-TS, and OsHKT2 were slightly different from the reported sequence, which may correspond to unreported haplotypes.
For the indica dispensable genome, 41,376 contigs which were assigned genomic positions relative to the Nipponbare genome were reassembled using local SNPs. About 70 % of them were reassembled with four to seven haplotypes (Figure S11 in Additional file 3). For about half of these 41,376 contigs, the longest local assembly was longer than the original contig. (Figure S11 in Additional file 3). The longest local assembly of about 5492 contigs of the indica dispensable genome were longer than the average length of the non-transposon loci of the rice Nipponbare reference genome (2853 bp) .
Population pattern of sequences of the dispensable genome
To explore the population patterns of the dispensable sequences, all the reads of the 1483 accessions that were not aligned to the Nipponbare reference genome were mapped to the dispensable genomes. The population composition of each contig was determined as the number of reads from accessions belonging to each of the three major subpopulations (indica, aus, and japonica) classified by whole genome SNPs, divided by the total number of the reads mapped to this contig (Figure S12 in Additional file 3). Great disparities were found in the population composition of reads aligned to different dispensable sequences. For 29,466 sequences of the indica dispensable genome, more than 80 % of the aligned reads were from a single subgroup. Similarly, 11,914 sequences of the japonica dispensable genome were composed of reads (≥80 % of total reads) mainly from a single subgroup. As the number of rice accessions and the sequencing coverage for each subpopulation were not uniform, the population composition of each contig was normalized through dividing the number of reads of each subpopulation by the total sequencing coverage of the corresponding subpopulation (Figure S12 in Additional file 3). A sequence was determined as subpopulation-preferred if the normalized proportion of mapped reads belonging to a specific subpopulation was larger than 0.8. We found 4879 of the contigs of the indica dispensable genome to be indica-preferred and 4211 were aus-preferred (Additional file 16) while only 80 were japonica-preferred. For 32,748 (61.8 %) indica dispensable sequences, the normalized proportion of mapped reads from japonica accessions was less than 0.1. Of all the japonica dispensable sequences, 1731 were japonica-preferred, 1453 were indica-preferred and 771 were aus-preferred. For only 4709 (15.5 %) japonica dispensable sequences was the normalized proportion of mapped reads from indica accessions less than 0.1. These results suggest that lots of sequences might have introgressed from the indica subspecies to the japonica subspecies.
We further investigated the read coverage rate of dispensable sequences for each subpopulation. For each contig of the dispensable genome, the read coverage rate was calculated by mapping raw reads of each accession to this contig and the highest read coverage rate for each subpopulation was taken as the read coverage rate for each subpopulation. The read coverage rates of all the three subpopulations for more than 40 % of the 52,976 contigs of the indica dispensable genome were higher than 80 % (Figure S13 in Additional file 3). The coverage rates of a lot of dispensable sequences were quite different among subpopulations. More sequences with higher coverage rates were found in indica than in japonica (Figure S13 in Additional file 3). This is consistent with the results of previous studies that the genome diversity of indica accessions is higher than the genome diversity of japonica .
The population pattern of each haplotype of the contigs in the dispensable genome was also examined. Interestingly, the sequence of PSTOL1, which was identified in the aus-type rice variety Kasalath, could be constructed accurately using reads from japonica accessions . This indicates the complexity of the population patterns of the dispensable genome.
The composition of dispensable sequences
To investigate the composition of dispensable sequences, we tried to explore the relationship between the dispensable sequences and the Nipponbare reference genome, especially the sequences of annotated genes. The sequences of exons and introns with a length greater than 200 bp were aligned to the contigs of the dispensable genomes using Blastn. If multiple exons/introns that were aligned to a contig overlapped with each other, only the one with the largest query coverage was retained. Only those exons/introns with more than 90 % of their sequences aligned to a contig were used for further analysis. In total, 5146 contigs of the indica dispensable genome contained multiple exons and introns from 6302 different reference genes (Figure S14a in Additional file 3; Additional file 17). Of all the 5146 contigs, 1165 (22.7 %) were aligned to the other sequenced Oryza genomes with improved match length (≥90 % of the length of the contig) compared with the alignment to the Nipponbare reference genome (≤50 % of the length of the contig), a proportion higher than the whole indica dispensable genome level (Fisher’s exact test, P ≤ 2.7e-24). Among these 6302 reference genes, 3893 were transposons or retrotransposons, 311 were annotated as expressed proteins, and 1101 were annotated as “hypothetical proteins” (release 6.1 of the MSU Rice Genome Annotation Project). The remaining 997 reference genes encoded proteins with potential functions, including OsWAK receptor-like protein kinase, disease resistance protein and jacalin-like lectin domain containing protein. Among these 6302 genes, genes encoding RNase, reverse transcriptase, protease, transposase, zinc finger, and plant mobile domain were found significantly enriched compared with the genes of the Nipponbare reference genome (Fisher’s exact test, P ≤ 1e-4; Additional file 18). For the japonica dispensable genome, 3120 contigs contained multiple exons and introns from 4278 different reference genes, among which genes encoding RNase, reverse transcriptase, protease, transposase, plant mobile domain, and salt stress response protein were found significantly enriched, which is quite similar to the indica dispensable genome.
The transposon composition of each contig of the indica dispensable genome was surveyed using the transposon annotation result provided by CENSOR . If more than 50 % of the sequence of a contig was annotated to contain at least two transposons, it was considered as a transposon cluster. As a result, 636 transposon clusters were detected within the indica dispensable genome, 215 (33.8 %) of which were aligned to the other sequenced Oryza genomes with improved match length (≥90 % of the length of the contig) compared with the alignment to the Nipponbare genome (≤50 % of the length of the contig) (Figure S14b in Additional file 3). More than half of the transposons involved in the formation of these 636 transposon clusters were MITEs (Additional file 19). We also downloaded all the long terminal repeat (LTR) retrotransposons from RetrOryza and aligned the internal regions and LTR regions to the contigs of the dispensable genome . An intact LTR retrotransposon contains two LTRs and an internal region. For the indica dispensable genome, 8668 (16 %) contigs were found to contain only one LTR or the internal region of a specific LTR retrotransposon and 896 (2 %) contigs contained at least two of the three elements of an LTR retrotransposon (Additional file 20). Among these 9564 contigs, 1198 (12.5 %) were aligned to the other sequenced Oryza genomes with improved match length (≥90 % of the length of the contig) compared with the alignment to the Nipponbare genome (≤50 % of the length of the contig).
In maize, rice, and Arabidopsis, a few Mutator-like transposable elements (MULEs) were shown to carry fragments of cellular genes, which were called Pack-MULEs. Jiang et al.  reported that over 3000 Pack-MULEs in rice contained fragments deriving from more than 1000 cellular genes. The indica dispensable genome was searched for Pack-MULEs following the procedures described by a previous study . As a result, 35 Pack-MULEs were found to carry fragments of 37 cellular genes (Additional file 21). Twenty of these 37 cellular genes were annotated to encode hypothetical proteins while several genes were annotated to encode myb domain proteins and zinc finger proteins.
Association mapping of agronomic and metabolic traits using the dispensable genome
Since the results of the population pattern analysis suggest that different rice accessions have different sequence compositions in their dispensable genomes, the differences in the dispensable sequences might be regarded as markers to investigate their contributions to phenotypic variation. Accordingly, we aligned all the reads unmapped to the Nipponbare genome to both the indica and japonica dispensable genomes and calculated the sequencing depth of each accession at every genomic position for each dispensable sequence (“Materials and methods”). Then each dispensable sequence was split into 500-bp overlapping windows (with 250-bp step size) and the average read depth in each window was calculated for each rice accession. Since the depth value for a specified 500-bp window varied among different accessions, it is referred to as a depth polymorphism (DP). The continuous data of DPs [termed continuous DPs (CDPs)] were transformed into Boolean values [termed Boolean DPs (BDPs)] (“Materials and methods”). A total of 463,765 DPs were constructed and 412,320 (88.9 %) were assigned genomic positions relative to the Nipponbare reference genome. Among the 1483 accessions, 533 accessions were collected and sequenced by us in a previous study with available phenotypic values for agronomic and metabolic traits . We further carried out GWASs using both CDPs and BDPs.
We first performed a GWAS for rice grain width using both a set of 3.9 million SNPs identified by mapping reads against the reference genome in a previous study  and the 0.46 million DPs (Fig. 7a, b). A sharp peak with a lead SNP, sf0505373357 (P = 1.3 × 10−24), 12 kb away from the cloned grain size gene GW5 was identified (Figure S15a in Additional file 3). When using CDPs, the DP marker OsIPC05060021-1251-1650 (Fig. 7a) was most significant (P = 9.9 × 10−23) and another DP marker, OsJPC05060030-1-500, was the second most significant (P = 1.9 × 10−22). When using BDPs, these two markers became more significant (OsIPC05060021-1251-1650, P = 5.8 × 10−37; OsJPC05060030-1-500, P = 2.1 × 10−36). The first DP marker is from contig OsIPC05060021 of the indica dispensable genome and the second is from contig OsJPC05060030 of the japonica dispensable genome, both of which contain a large part of the GW5/qSW5 coding region, which can be fully constructed by local de novo reassembly (Fig. 7b). GW5 encodes a novel nuclear protein which is deleted from the Nipponbare genome and thus has not been annotated in any rice genome annotation (Fig. 7b).
We further carried out GWASs using linear mixed model (LMM) for rice metabolic traits, including 840 metabolites , using CDPs and BDPs. A set of 524 rice accessions were cultivated in two places and the collection of samples and metabolite profiling were performed separately; thus, the two replicates could be analyzed independently, generating a total of 1680 metabolic traits. After performing GWASs, the most significant SNP (termed the lead SNP), CDP and BDP for each trait were recorded and compared. In all, 854 traits with SNPs, 935 traits with CDPs and 790 traits with BDPs passed the genome-wide significance threshold (P = 6.6 × 10−8). Around 23.4 % (219/935) of the most significant CDPs and 11.4 % (90/790) of BDPs could not be located on the reference genome. Compared with the highest association signals identified using SNPs , we found that 23.5 % (220/935) and 16.6 % (131/790) of metabolites had stronger association signals (100 times smaller P values) with CDPs and BDPs, respectively (Fig. 7c; Figure S15c in Additional file 3). For 41.6 % of the 854 traits associated with significant SNPs, the most significant SNPs had concordant genomic locations (<100 kb) with significant CDPs (P ≤ 6.6 × 10−8) or similarly significant (the difference of P values less than 100 times) CDPs (Fig. 7d; Additional file 22). These results suggest that the dispensable sequences are an important part of the genome associated with phenotypic traits and underlying causes of missing heritability .
The dispensable sequences present in the population but absent from the reference assembly are important to understanding the genetic repertoire of a species . The usual way to construct such non-reference sequences is assembling the deep-sequencing data of representative individuals [1, 7]. In this study, a metagenome-like assembly strategy was adopted to identify dispensable sequences by de novo assembly of low-coverage population sequencing data of 1483 rice accessions. Sequence heterozygosity, which was demonstrated as a major challenge facing this metagenome-like assembly strategy, was partly resolved by use of a large sample size to provide adequate sequencing depth for lots of dispensable sequences and categorizing the population into two groups to reduce the sequence diversity within the same group. Each dispensable sequence was assigned a genomic position relative to the Nipponbare reference genome. In addition, accurate sequences for different haplotypes of each dispensable sequence were constructed utilizing a local de novo reassembly strategy, which was shown to be an efficient solution to sequence heterozygosity. Various forms of evidence proved the feasibility and efficiency of these strategies. With the advance of next-generation sequencing and the availability of more and more population sequencing data , these strategies will become more useful for future studies in rice and other species.
We performed association mapping studies for agronomical and metabolic traits using dispensable sequences. GWASs have been fruitful in many species, especially in human. However, only SNPs that were identified against a reference genome have been used in nearly all studies. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first large-scale association mapping study using dispensable genomes. We found that 23.5 % of metabolic traits had higher association signals with polymorphisms of dispensable sequences than SNPs of the reference genome and 41.6 % of trait-associated SNPs had genomic locations concordant with associated dispensable sequences. These results suggest that the dispensable genome should be taken into account in association mapping and is an underlying cause of missing heritability. The dispensable sequences provide not only additional associated markers but also candidate genes, both of which are valuable resources for QTL mapping and GWASs.
Rice is an important crop that feeds half of the world population. Its yield and biotic/abiotic resistance need to be greatly improved in the coming decades to solve food shortages caused by population growth. In this study, more than 8000 protein-coding genes absent from the Nipponbare reference genome were successfully constructed. A proportion of proteins with annotated domains and families related to disease or stress resistance were found in the dispensable genome, such as LRR and NB-ARC domain-containing proteins, the stress-antifung family and WRKY family proteins. Together, these imply that the rice dispensable genome contains a significant amount of genetic resources that are useful for rice phenotype improvement.
Exploring the relationship between the dispensable genome and the reference genome is helpful for inspecting genome evolution. In this study, we observed 833 chromosome hotspots enriched with dispensable sequences. The formation mechanism of these hotspots needs further investigation. We also found 5146 contigs of the indica dispensable genome to be composed of exons and introns of different reference genes. Among 6302 annotated reference genes, the genes which encode enzymes and NBS-LRR domains were found to be significantly enriched compared with genes of the Nipponbare reference genome. This may indicate that parts of the dispensable sequences are formed by the shuffling of exons and introns of reference genes, which was reported to be involved in the formation of novel enzymes and NBS-LRR genes [60, 61]. Within the indica dispensable genome, 636 transposon clusters were found, more than 50 % of whose sequences contained at least two transposons. In addition, 8668 contigs were found to contain only one LTR or the internal region of a specific LTR retrotransposon and 896 contigs contained at least two of the three elements of a LTR retrotransposon. This indicates that the deletion of LTR retrotransposons, which was reported to be involved in the evolution of the rice genome, may contribute to the composition of the rice dispensable genome [2, 62]. All in all, our study, for the first time, has explored the dispensable genome of a higher organism at the population level. These findings will shed light on studies of new gene evolution, genome evolution and speciation.
Our results suggest the feasibility and advantages of building the dispensable genome of a species using low-coverage population sequencing data. The sequences constructed will be helpful for understanding the rice dispensable genome and complementary to the reference genome for picking candidate genes associated with variations of agronomic and metabolic traits.
Materials and methods
Collection of sequence data
Low coverage (~1–3×) sequencing data of 1483 cultivated rice accessions, comprising 11.3 billion reads, were downloaded from the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) Sequence Read Archive (SRA) [GenBank: PRJNA171289] and European Nucleotide Archive [EMBL: ERP000106, ERP000729] (Additional file 1) .
Genetic structure analysis of the rice population
We performed discriminant analysis of principal components based on 206,189 evenly distributed SNPs and classified the rice accessions into subgroups using the dapc function in the R package adegenet . For SNP selection, we split the genome into ~5-kb regions; at most, three SNPs with minor allele frequencies ≥0.1 were randomly chosen for each region. The 1483 rice accessions were classified into four subgroups, indica, aus, temperate japonica, and tropical japonica, based on the results of population structure analysis and previous studies [8, 19]. Accessions of indica and aus groups were used to construct the indica dispensable genome while accessions of temperate japonica and tropical japonica groups were used to construct the japonica dispensable genome.
Extraction of reads that could not be mapped to the reference genome
Both reads of a read pair of which at least one read could not be mapped to the Nipponbare reference genome (release 6.1 of the MSU Rice Genome Annotation Project) were collected to do de novo assembly. The mapped read is helpful for determining the relationship between the assembly results and the Nipponbare reference genome, and for inspecting the distribution of insertions in the Nipponbare genome. A stringent filtering rule was employed to remove low quality reads prior to assembly (Additional file 12). Jellyfish (version 1.1.5)  and Quake (version 0.3.0)  were used for computing k-mer frequencies and correcting sequencing errors in the reads before assembly (Additional file 12).
The metagenome-like assembly strategy
Due to the low sequencing coverage of each accession, reads of various accessions were combined to do de novo assembly. The greatest challenge facing this approach is the substantial sequence variations between different accessions. To address this challenge, an assembly strategy used in metagenomic studies was introduced, since the mixed population sequencing data are similar to metagenomic sequencing data, which are a mixture of multiple species of a community. First, due to the substantial genomic differences between rice subspecies, all the 1483 accessions were categorized into two groups corresponding to either indica and japonica subspecies of rice and based on accession information and whole genome SNPs. Second, reads of each group were assembled independently using two assemblers, SOAPdenovo (version 1.05)  and Meta-IDBA (version 0.20, default parameters)  (Fig. 1a), which have been used widely in metagenomic studies . SOAPdenovo (k-mer set as 63) was used with the specific parameter ‘-M 3’ as recommended for metagenomic data by a previous study . Meta-IDBA is an iterative de Bruijn graph short read assembler specially designed for de novo metagenomic assembly. After discarding sequences shorter than 500 bp, the results of GICL were considered as the final assembly.
Removal of contamination from the assembly result
Part of the reads which could not be mapped to the Nipponbare genome might be contamination. These sequences must be removed before further analysis. DeconSeq (version 0.4.1)  was applied in this step (Fig. 1a) in which several genome sequences were used to build the “remove” databases and the “retain” databases. The remove databases were used to screen for contaminations while the retain databases were used to eliminate redundant hits with higher similarity to non-contaminant genomes. Bacterial genomes, viral genomes, influenza genomes, and the human reference genome were all used to build the remove databases in this study while several plant genomes were used as the retain databases. Stringent parameters (5 % for coverage threshold, 90 % for identity threshold) were used for DeconSeq to filter potential contamination. All the genome sequences were downloaded from NCBI .
After the filtering by DeconSeq, the remaining sequences were further aligned to the NCBI Nucleotide collection database using Blastn (version 2.2.18)  to remove contamination. Sequences that were aligned to all sequenced plant genomes with matched lengths smaller than 300 bp were not subject to further analysis because of the difficulty of annotation, but these sequences are available for download from the Panrice website .
PCR validation of de novo assembly
To evaluate the accuracy of the de novo assembly, PCR validation was performed using 30 contigs randomly selected from contigs with poor alignment (Blastn, query coverage <20 %) to any of the five sequenced genomes of the Oryza genus. PCR primers were designed to amplify DNA fragments with lengths ranging from 1162 bp to 2077 bp from these 30 randomly selected contigs (Additional file 5). For each contig, all the sequencing reads of different rice accessions were aligned to the contig using BWA (version 0.6.1)  and the genomic DNA of the rice accession with the highest read coverage for this contig was used as a template. For comparison, the genomic DNA of Nipponbare was also amplified using the designed primers of each contig.
Sequenced genomes of the Oryza genus
Five sequenced genomes of the Oryza genus were used in this study: Oryza sativa L. ssp. japonica (Nipponbare) , Oryza sativa L. ssp. indica (93-11) [26, 70], Oryza glaberrima (African cultivated rice) [27, 70], Oryza brachyantha (African wild rice) [28, 70], and Oryza rufipogon (W1943, Asian wild rice) . The genome sequences of Oryza glaberrima, Oryza brachyantha, and Oryza rufipogon were the results of the Oryza Map Alignment Project (OMAP), which aimed to generate reference sequences for collective Oryza genomes .
Annotation of the assembly results
In spite of the successful construction of several cloned genes, the contig sequences obtained are expected to be error-prone. Annotation of these contigs is more troublesome than that of the usual genome. An integrative annotation pipeline was applied to predict protein-coding genes in the dispensable genome sequences (Additional file 12). Two ab initio gene predictors, Fgenesh (version 3.1.2)  and AUGUSTUS (version 2.5.5) , were used to predict protein-coding genes de novo. All the protein sequences of the grass family were downloaded from Gramene  and used as input to GeneWise (version 2.2.0) , which predicts protein-coding genes based on the homology between protein sequences and genome sequences. All the RNA-seq data of rice were downloaded from the NCBI SRA database and the website of the Comai Lab . Low quality reads were filtered out by a stringent rule (Additional file 12) and the high quality reads were then mapped to the contigs using TopHat (version 2.0.4) . Transcripts were further obtained from the mapping results using inchworm (version 2011-03-13) to do reference-guided assembly . The assembled transcripts were then mapped to the contigs using PASA (version 2011-05-20)  and gmap (version 2012-04-05) . Finally, the prediction results of Fgenesh, AUGUSTUS, and GeneWise and the alignment result of PASA were combined by EvidenceModeler (version 2012-06-25) , and were further used as input to PASA for updating. Predicted genes which could be aligned to the Nipponbare reference genome with ≥85 % coverage and ≥85 % identity were further removed to eliminate potential paralogs. The predicted genes that satisfied at least one of the following two rules were regarded as high confidence genes. First, more than 90 % of the coding region of a predicted gene is covered by protein sequences of the grass family and more than 60 % of the coding region is covered by any transcript assembled by inchworm. Second, the protein coded by a predicted gene can be aligned to a protein of the grass family with reciprocal coordinate overlap of more than 90 %.
To annotate transposable elements within the assembled contigs of the dispensable genomes, CENSOR (version 4.2.27)  was used taking the Oryza transposons in Repbase  as the repetitive library. The only transposons annotated were those with more than 80 % of their sequences aligned to a contig of the dispensable genome.
Expression profiling of predicted genes of the dispensable genome
RNA sequencing data of ten experiments (Additional file 10) were collected from NCBI SRA database and the website of the Comai lab. These data were aligned to the dispensable genome independently using TopHat  with the predicted genes’ structures as input. The alignments were then used as input to Cufflinks (version 1.2.1) to assemble the reads into transcripts and quantify the expression level of each transcript .
Identifying genomic positions relative to the Nipponbare genome from literature for genes absent from the Nipponbare genome
For PSTOL1, the bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) sequence was reported to correspond to a 145-kb sequence interval between positions 15,321,347 and 15,466,417 on chromosome 12 of Nipponbare RefSeq (TIGR/MSU version 5). This genomic interval corresponds to positions between 15,321,347 and 15,466,417 on chromosome 12 of MSU version 6.1. The genomic position for PSTOL1 was determined based on its position in the BAC sequence. Since the gene Sub1B was reported to be about 45 kb away from Sub1A, its sequence was aligned to the pseudomolecules of MSU version 6.1 and the resulting genomic interval was regarded as the genomic position of Sub1A. The BAC sequence harboring Pikm1-TS and Pikm2-TS was aligned to the pseudomolecules of MSU version 6.1 to get a genomic interval and the genomic positions of Pikm1-TS and Pikm2-TS were determined based on their positions in this BAC. The reported sequence [GenBank: AB433345] (11,150 bp) containing GW5 of rice accession Kasalath was aligned to the pseudomolecules of MSU version 6.1 to get a genomic interval and the genomic position of GW5 was determined based on its position in this sequence. The reported sequence [GenBank: AY986492] (2361 bp) containing Xa27 of rice accession IRBB27 was aligned to the pseudomolecules of MSU version 6.1 to get a genomic interval and the genomic position of Xa27 was determined based on its position in this sequence.
Local de novo reassembly strategy
For a contig that can be assigned a genomic position relative to the Nipponbare genome, the distance between any two of the 1483 rice accessions was calculated using the 100 SNPs of the Nipponbare genome around this contig and accessions with a distance of zero between each other were grouped together. For a contig that could not be assigned a genomic position, all the 1483 rice accessions were divided into six groups based on the distance calculated using the whole genome SNPs (Additional file 23). Then the read pairs of each subgroup that could be mapped to this contig were assembled separately using Fuzzypath  (parameter “kmer” set as 31).
Association mapping using the dispensable genomes
The sequencing depth of the dispensable sequences of each accession could be regarded as markers, which we termed “depth polymorphisms”. For each of the 533 rice accessions that we sequenced at ~2.5×, reads unmapped to the Nipponbare reference genome were aligned to both the indica and japonica dispensable genomes and the read depth at each position was obtained using SAMtools (samtools depth -q 10 -Q 20). Then the average read depth in 500-bp overlapping windows (with 250-bp step size) were computed for each rice accession. The average read depth larger than eight was arbitrarily set as eight. The depth values were further corrected by accounting for the average sequencing depth of each accession. We then transformed the continuous data (termed continuous DPs) into Boolean values (termed Boolean DPs) by setting out a threshold of 0.1 by manual inspection (values less than 0.1 were set to 0 and greater than 0.1 were set to 1). Only CDPs with the frequency of both 0 and 1 in BDPs ≥0.05 were used to carry out GWASs. We performed GWASs using methods described in our previous study , except that the FaST-LMM program was replaced by EMMAX , which is implemented in R from the MLMM package  and could deal with continuous values. The genetic and residual variance components were estimated by the restricted maximum likelihood (REML) method. The kinship coefficients (K matrix) used in linear mixed model were defined as the proportion of identical genotypes for 188,165 randomly sampled, evenly distributed SNPs for each pair of individuals, as were used in a previous study . A total of 3,916,415 SNPs with minor allele frequency ≥0.05 that were identified by mapping reads to the reference genome in a previous study  for the same association panel were used to carry out GWASs. To save computing resources, only the most significant 1000 SNPs for each metabolic trait identified by FaST-LMM previously  were extracted and combined with CDP and BDP data to carry out GWASs using EMMAX. The genome-wide significance threshold (P = 6.6 × 10−8) used in a previous study for the same association panel was adopted .
bacterial artificial chromosome
Boolean depth polymorphism
continuous depth polymorphism
genome-wide association study
Linear mixed model
long terminal repeat
miniature inverted-repeat transposable element
Michigan State University
Mutator-like transposable element
National Center for Biotechnology Information
polymerase chain reaction
quantitative trait locus
reads/per kilobase merged exonic region/per million mapped reads
single nucleotide polymorphism
Sequence Read Archive.
Li R, Li Y, Zheng H, Luo R, Zhu H, Li Q, et al. Building the sequence map of the human pan-genome. Nat Biotechnol. 2009;28:57–63.
Morgante M, De Paoli E, Radovic S. Transposable elements and the plant pan-genomes. Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2007;10:149–55.
Marroni F, Pinosio S, Morgante M. Structural variation and genome complexity: is dispensable really dispensable? Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2014;18:31–6.
Medini D, Donati C, Tettelin H, Masignani V, Rappuoli R. The microbial pan-genome. Curr Opin Genet Dev. 2005;15:589–94.
Hirsch CN, Foerster JM, Johnson JM, Sekhon RS, Muttoni G, Vaillancourt B, et al. Insights into the maize pan-genome and pan-transcriptome. Plant Cell. 2014;26:121–35.
Tettelin H. Genome analysis of multiple pathogenic isolates of Streptococcus agalactiae: Implications for the microbial “pan-genome”. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2005;102:13950–5.
Y-h L, Zhou G, Ma J, Jiang W, Jin L-g, Zhang Z, et al. De novo assembly of soybean wild relatives for pan-genome analysis of diversity and agronomic traits. Nat Biotechnol. 2014;32:1045–52.
Huang X, Zhao Y, Wei X, Li C, Wang A, Zhao Q, et al. Genome-wide association study of flowering time and grain yield traits in a worldwide collection of rice germplasm. Nat Genet. 2011;44:32–9.
Chen W, Gao Y, Xie W, Gong L, Lu K, Wang W, et al. Genome-wide association analyses provide genetic and biochemical insights into natural variation in rice metabolism. Nat Genet. 2014;46:714–21.
Xie W, Feng Q, Yu H, Huang X, Zhao Q, Xing Y, et al. Parent-independent genotyping for constructing an ultrahigh-density linkage map based on population sequencing. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010;107:10578–83.
International Rice Genome Sequencing Project. The map-based sequence of the rice genome. Nature. 2005;436:793–800.
Jiang Y, Cai Z, Xie W, Long T, Yu H, Zhang Q. Rice functional genomics research: Progress and implications for crop genetic improvement. Biotechnol Adv. 2012;30:1059–70.
Shomura A, Izawa T, Ebana K, Ebitani T, Kanegae H, Konishi S, et al. Deletion in a gene associated with grain size increased yields during rice domestication. Nat Genet. 2008;40:1023–8.
Xu K, Xu X, Fukao T, Canlas P, Maghirang-Rodriguez R, Heuer S, et al. Sub1A is an ethylene-response-factor-like gene that confers submergence tolerance to rice. Nature. 2006;442:705–8.
Ashikawa I, Hayashi N, Yamane H, Kanamori H, Wu J, Matsumoto T, et al. Two adjacent nucleotide-binding site-leucine-rich repeat class genes are required to confer Pikm-specific rice blast resistance. Genetics. 2008;180:2267–76.
Kawahara Y, de la Bastide M, Hamilton J, Kanamori H, McCombie W, Ouyang S, et al. Improvement of the Oryza sativa Nipponbare reference genome using next generation sequence and optical map data. Rice. 2013;6:1–10.
Zhao H, Yao W, Ouyang Y, Yang W, Wang G, Lian X, et al. RiceVarMap: a comprehensive database of rice genomic variations. Nucleic Acids Res. 2015;43:D1018–22.
Huang X, Wei X, Sang T, Zhao Q, Feng Q, Zhao Y, et al. Genome-wide association studies of 14 agronomic traits in rice landraces. Nat Genet. 2010;42:961–7.
Li H, Durbin R. Fast and accurate short read alignment with Burrows-Wheeler transform. Bioinformatics. 2009;25:1754–60.
Li R, Zhu H, Ruan J, Qian W, Fang X, Shi Z, et al. De novo assembly of human genomes with massively parallel short read sequencing. Genome Res. 2010;20:265–72.
Peng Y, Leung HCM, Yiu SM, Chin FYL. Meta-IDBA: a de Novo assembler for metagenomic data. Bioinformatics. 2011;27:i94–101.
Pertea G, Huang X, Liang F, Antonescu V, Sultana R, Karamycheva S, et al. TIGR Gene Indices clustering tools (TGICL): a software system for fast clustering of large EST datasets. Bioinformatics. 2003;19:651–2.
Marcais G, Kingsford C. A fast, lock-free approach for efficient parallel counting of occurrences of k-mers. Bioinformatics. 2011;27:764–70.
Gao L-z. Innan H. Nonindependent domestication of the Two rice subspecies, Oryza sativa ssp. indica and ssp. japonica, demonstrated by multilocus microsatellites. Genetics. 2008;179:965–76.
Yu J, Hu S, Wang J, Wong GK, Li S, Liu B, et al. A draft sequence of the rice genome (Oryza sativa L. ssp. indica). Science. 2002;296:79–92.
Sakai H, Ikawa H, Tanaka T, Numa H, Minami H, Fujisawa M, et al. Distinct evolutionary patterns of Oryza glaberrima deciphered by genome sequencing and comparative analysis. Plant J. 2011;66:796–805.
Chen J, Huang Q, Gao D, Wang J, Lang Y, Liu T, et al. Whole-genome sequencing of Oryza brachyantha reveals mechanisms underlying Oryza genome evolution. Nat Commun. 2013;4:1595.
Huang X, Kurata N, Wei X, Wang Z-X, Wang A, Zhao Q, et al. A map of rice genome variation reveals the origin of cultivated rice. Nature. 2012;490:497–501.
Weng J, Gu S, Wan X, Gao H, Guo T, Su N, et al. Isolation and initial characterization of GW5, a major QTL associated with rice grain width and weight. Cell Res. 2008;18:1199–209.
Wang Z-X, Yano M, Yamanouchi U, Iwamoto M, Monna L, Hayasaka H, et al. The Pib gene for rice blast resistance belongs to the nucleotide binding and leucine-rich repeat class of plant disease resistance genes. Plant J. 1999;19:55–64.
Gu K, Yang B, Tian D, Wu L, Wang D, Sreekala C, et al. R gene expression induced by a type-III effector triggers disease resistance in rice. Nature. 2005;435:1122–5.
Hattori Y, Nagai K, Furukawa S, Song X-J, Kawano R, Sakakibara H, et al. The ethylene response factors SNORKEL1 and SNORKEL2 allow rice to adapt to deep water. Nature. 2009;460:1026–30.
Horie T, Yoshida K, Nakayama H, Yamada K, Oiki S, Shinmyo A. Two types of HKT transporters with different properties of Na + and K+ transport in Oryza sativa. Plant J. 2001;27:129–38.
Gamuyao R, Chin JH, Pariasca-Tanaka J, Pesaresi P, Catausan S, Dalid C, et al. The protein kinase Pstol1 from traditional rice confers tolerance of phosphorus deficiency. Nature. 2012;488:535–9.
Heuer S, Lu X, Chin JH, Tanaka JP, Kanamori H, Matsumoto T, et al. Comparative sequence analyses of the major quantitative trait locusphosphorusuptake1(Pup1) reveal a complex genetic structure. Plant Biotechnol J. 2009;7:456–71.
Lu T, Yu S, Fan D, Mu J, Shangguan Y, Wang Z, et al. Collection and comparative analysis of 1888 full-length cDNAs from wild rice Oryza rufipogon Griff. W1943. DNA Res. 2008;15:285–95.
Salamov AA, Solovyev VV. Ab initio gene finding in Drosophila genomic DNA. Genome Res. 2000;10:516–22.
Stanke M, Schöffmann O, Morgenstern B, Waack S. Gene prediction in eukaryotes with a generalized hidden Markov model that uses hints from external sources. BMC Bioinformatics. 2006;7:62.
Birney E, Clamp M, Durbin R. GeneWise and Genomewise. Genome Res. 2004;14:988–95.
Haas BJ, Delcher AL, Mount SM, Wortman JR, Smith Jr RK, Hannick LI, et al. Improving the Arabidopsis genome annotation using maximal transcript alignment assemblies. Nucleic Acids Res. 2003;31:5654–66.
Haas B, Salzberg S, Zhu W, Pertea M, Allen J, Orvis J, et al. Automated eukaryotic gene structure annotation using EVidenceModeler and the Program to Assemble Spliced Alignments. Genome Biol. 2008;9:R7.
Altschul SF, Gish W, Miller W, Myers EW, Lipman DJ. Basic local alignment search tool. J Mol Biol. 1990;215:403–10.
Lu F-H, Park Y-J. An SNP downstream of the OsBEIIb gene is significantly associated with amylose content and viscosity properties in rice (Oryza sativa L.). J Cereal Sci. 2012;56:706–12.
Finn RD, Mistry J, Tate J, Coggill P, Heger A, Pollington JE, et al. The Pfam protein families database. Nucleic Acids Res. 2010;38:D211–22.
Fedoroff NV. Transposable elements, epigenetics, and genome evolution. Science. 2012;338:758–67.
Plant Repeat Databases. http://plantrepeats.plantbiology.msu.edu/about.html.
Smith JJ, Sumiyama K, Amemiya CT. A living fossil in the genome of a living fossil: harbinger transposons in the coelacanth genome. Mol Biol Evol. 2012;29:985–93.
Momose M, Abe Y, Ozeki Y. Miniature inverted-repeat transposable elements of stowaway are active in potato. Genetics. 2010;186:59–66.
Yang G, Nagel DH, Feschotte C, Hancock CN, Wessler SR. Tuned for transposition: molecular determinants underlying the hyperactivity of a stowaway MITE. Science. 2009;325:1391–4.
Trapnell C, Pachter L, Salzberg SL. TopHat: discovering splice junctions with RNA-Seq. Bioinformatics. 2009;25:1105–11.
Kohany O, Gentles A, Hankus L, Jurka J. Annotation, submission and screening of repetitive elements in Repbase: RepbaseSubmitter and Censor. BMC Bioinformatics. 2006;7:474.
Chaparro C, Guyot R, Zuccolo A, Piégu B, Panaud O. RetrOryza: a database of the rice LTR-retrotransposons. Nucleic Acids Res. 2007;35:D66–70.
Jiang N, Bao Z, Zhang X, Eddy SR, Wessler SR. Pack-MULE transposable elements mediate gene evolution in plants. Nature. 2004;431:569–73.
Jiang N, Ferguson AA, Slotkin RK, Lisch D. Pack-Mutator-like transposable elements (Pack-MULEs) induce directional modification of genes through biased insertion and DNA acquisition. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011;108:1537–42.
Eichler EE, Flint J, Gibson G, Kong A, Leal SM, Moore JH, et al. Missing heritability and strategies for finding the underlying causes of complex disease. Nat Rev Genet. 2010;11:446–50.
The 3,000 rice genomes project. The 3,000 rice genomes project. GigaScience. 2014;3:7.
Nixon AE, Warren MS, Benkovic SJ. Assembly of an active enzyme by the linkage of two protein modules. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1997;94:1069–73.
Hammond-Kosack KE, Jones JDG. Plant disease resistance genes. Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol. 1997;48:575.
Ma J, Devos KM, Bennetzen JL. Analyses of LTR-retrotransposon structures reveal recent and rapid genomic DNA loss in rice. Genome Res. 2004;14:860–9.
Jombart T, Ahmed I. adegenet 1.3-1: new tools for the analysis of genome-wide SNP data. Bioinformatics. 2011;27:3070–1.
Kelley DR, Schatz MC, Salzberg SL. Quake: quality-aware detection and correction of sequencing errors. Genome Biol. 2010;11:R116.
Baker KS, Leggett RM, Bexfield NH, Alston M, Daly G, Todd S, et al. Metagenomic study of the viruses of African straw-coloured fruit bats: Detection of a chiropteran poxvirus and isolation of a novel adenovirus. Virology. 2013;441:95–106.
Qin J, Li R, Raes J, Arumugam M, Burgdorf KS, Manichanh C, et al. A human gut microbial gene catalogue established by metagenomic sequencing. Nature. 2010;464:59–65.
Rodriguez-Valera F, Schmieder R, Edwards R. Fast identification and removal of sequence contamination from genomic and metagenomic datasets. PLoS One. 2011;6, e17288.
Rice Genome Annotation Project. http://rice.plantbiology.msu.edu/.
National Center for Gene Research. http://www.ncgr.ac.cn/.
Goicoechea J, Ammiraju J, Marri P, Chen M, Jackson S, Yu Y, et al. The future of rice genomics: sequencing the collective Oryza genome. Rice. 2010;3:89–97.
ComaiWiki: rice RNA-Seq sequence files. http://comailab.genomecenter.ucdavis.edu/index.php/Rice_RNA-Seq.
Grabherr MG, Haas BJ, Yassour M, Levin JZ, Thompson DA, Amit I, et al. Full-length transcriptome assembly from RNA-Seq data without a reference genome. Nat Biotechnol. 2011;29:644–52.
Wu TD, Watanabe CK. GMAP: a genomic mapping and alignment program for mRNA and EST sequences. Bioinformatics. 2005;21:1859–75.
Jurka J, Kapitonov VV, Pavlicek A, Klonowski P, Kohany O, Walichiewicz J. Repbase Update, a database of eukaryotic repetitive elements. Cytogenet Genome Res. 2005;110:462–7.
Trapnell C, Williams BA, Pertea G, Mortazavi A, Kwan G, van Baren MJ, et al. Transcript assembly and quantification by RNA-Seq reveals unannotated transcripts and isoform switching during cell differentiation. Nat Biotechnol. 2010;28:511–5.
Kang HM, Sul JH, Service SK, Zaitlen NA, Kong S-y, Freimer NB, et al. Variance component model to account for sample structure in genome-wide association studies. Nat Genet. 2010;42:348–54.
Segura V, Vilhjalmsson BJ, Platt A, Korte A, Seren U, Long Q, et al. An efficient multi-locus mixed-model approach for genome-wide association studies in structured populations. Nat Genet. 2012;44:825–30.
We thank Prof. Chengjun Zhang at Kunming Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Prof. Guoliang Li at Huazhong Agricultural University, and anonymous reviewers for their valuable suggestions and help with improving the manuscript, and Dr. David Kudrna for English editing. This work was supported by grants from the National High Technology Research and Development Program of China (863 Program: 2012AA10A304, 2014AA10A602), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (31571375, 31123009) and the Project Program of National Key Laboratory of Crop Genetic Improvement.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
WX conceived the study, analyzed the data and wrote the manuscript. WY analyzed the data and wrote the manuscript. GL performed the PCR experiments. HZ built the Panrice website. GW and XL contributed the DNA sequencing data and some of the rice plant materials. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Collection of sequence data. (DOCX 14 kb)
Mapping rate of sequencing reads aligned to the Nipponbare genome of different accessions. (XLS 107 kb)
Supplementary figures. (PDF 3352 kb)
Alignment of contigs of the indica dispensable genome to different sequenced genomes of the Oryza genus. (XLS 8272 kb)
PCR validation of 43 DNA fragments from 30 randomly selected contigs. Primer position is the position of a primer in the sequence of the contig. (XLS 19 kb)
The alignment of genes in the sequenced region of Kasalath that harbors PSTOL1 to the dispensable genome. (XLS 17 kb)
Blastn alignment result of the full-length cDNA sequences of 12 O. rufipogon genes to the contigs of the dispensable genome. (DOC 35 kb)
The alignment of predicted proteins of the indica dispensable genome to proteins coded by cloned genes of the Nipponbare genome using Blastp. (XLS 33 kb)
The Pfam annotation results of the predicted proteins of the indica dispensable genome. See the Pfam website  for more details. (XLS 222 kb)
RNA sequencing data used in the expression profiling of predicted genes of the dispensable genome. (XLS 10 kb)
Sheet 1 shows the transposon annotation results of the indica dispensable genome given by Censor. Sheet 2 is the transposon annotation results of the japonica dispensable genome given by Censor. (XLS 5583 kb)
Supplementary methods. (PDF 356 kb)
Sheet 1 shows the genomic position relative to the Nipponbare genome for contigs of the indica dispensable genome. Sheet 2 shows the genomic position relative to the Nipponbare genome for contigs of the japonica dispensable genome. (XLS 22307 kb)
The genomic positions relative to the Nipponbare genome of overlapping contigs of the indica and japonica dispensable genomes. Genomic positions were determined using an integration approach based on alignment and linkage disequilibrium for 7820 indica contigs corresponding to 7689 japonica contigs which were found to have reciprocal coordinate overlap of more than 60 % (identity ≥90 %). (XLS 1582 kb)
Identified chromosome insertion hotspots. (XLS 51 kb)
Sheet 1 shows contigs of the indica dispensable genome that were composed by reads mainly from a subgroup. Sheet 2 shows contigs of the japonica dispensable genome that were composed by reads mainly from a subgroup. Columns 2–4 show the percentage of reads mapped to the contig that belong to each subgroup. (XLS 1556 kb)
Sheet 1 shows the contigs of the indica dispensable genome related to exon/intron shuffling. Sheet 2 displays the contigs of the japonica dispensable genome related to exon/intron shuffling. (XLS 3716 kb)
Functional enrichment analysis of 6302 reference genes involved in the formation of non-reference sequences through exon/intron shuffling. The hmm accession for all the 6302 reference genes was extracted, and the number of genes with a specific hmm accession involved in the formation of non-reference sequences through exon/intron shuffling were compared with the whole genome level to find enriched accessions. In total, 3581 of these 6302 genes and 33,581 genes of the whole genome were annotated by Pfam. (DOC 40 kb)
Sheet 1 shows the transposon clusters found within the indica dispensable genome. Sheet 2 shows the transposon clusters found within the japonica dispensable genome. The second to sixth columns show the percentage of query coverage of the alignment of the contig to different sequenced Oryza genome. (XLS 323 kb)
LTR retrotransposons found within the dispensable genome. (XLS 2869 kb)
Pack-MULEs found within the indica dispensable genome. (XLS 15 kb)
Association mapping results of metabolic traits using whole genome SNPs or depth polymorphisms of the dispensable genome. Lead_SNP is the SNP with the most significant association signal for a specific metabolic trait. Chromosome is the chromosome position of Lead_SNP. Position is the chromosome position of Lead_SNP. P value is the association P value for Lead_SNP. Close_DP is the associated depth polymorphism closest to Lead_SNP. Close_DP_P value is the association P value for close_DP. Close_DP_Position is the genomic position of Close_DP relative to the Nipponbare genome. Close_DP_Distance is the distance (kb) between the Lead_SNP and the Close_DP. Lead_CDP is the continuous depth polymorphism with the most significant association signal for a specific metabolic trait. Lead_CDP_P value is the association P value for Lead_CDP. Lead_CDP_Pfam is the Pfam prediction result for Lead_CDP. Lead_BDP is the Boolean depth polymorphism with the most significant association signal for a specific metabolic trait. Lead_BDP_P value is the association P value for Lead_BDP. Lead_BDP_Pfam is the Pfam prediction result for Lead_BDP. (XLS 496 kb)
The rice accessions were classified into six groups (groups A–F) to do local reassembly for contigs which could not be assigned genomic positions relative to the reference genome. (XLS 86 kb)