Skip to main content

Table 1 Accuracy measures for datasets simulated with Mason with various sequencing depths and error rates

From: Lighter: fast and memory-efficient sequencing error correction without counting

Coverage

 

35×

70×

140×

Error rate

 

1 %

3 %

1 %

3 %

1 %

3 %

α for Lighter

 

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

0.05

0.05

 

Quake

89.68

48.77

89.64

48.82

89.59

48.78

 

SOAPec

57.71

38.00

57.57

37.71

57.09

36.76

Recall

Musket

93.75

92.62

93.73

92.64

93.73

92.63

 

Bless

99.81

99.33

99.82

99.58

99.82

99.58

 

Lighter

99.87

98.53

99.84

98.72

99.86

98.78

 

Quake

99.99

99.99

99.99

99.99

99.99

99.99

 

SOAPec

99.99

100.00

99.99

99.99

99.99

99.99

Precision

Musket

99.99

99.93

99.99

99.93

99.99

99.93

 

Bless

99.73

98.86

99.73

99.35

99.72

99.36

 

Lighter

99.98

99.96

99.98

99.96

99.98

99.96

 

Quake

94.55

65.56

94.54

65.61

94.51

65.57

 

SOAPec

73.18

55.07

73.07

54.77

72.68

53.75

F score

Musket

96.77

96.14

96.76

96.15

96.76

96.15

 

Bless

99.77

99.09

99.77

99.47

99.77

99.47

 

Lighter

99.93

99.24

99.91

99.33

99.92

99.36

 

Quake

89.67

48.76

89.64

48.82

89.59

48.78

 

SOAPec

57.70

38.00

57.57

37.71

57.09

36.75

Gain

Musket

93.74

92.56

93.72

92.58

93.72

92.57

 

Bless

99.54

98.19

99.54

98.93

99.54

98.94

 

Lighter

99.85

98.49

99.81

98.68

99.84

98.73

 

Quake

17

17

17

17

17

17

 

SOAPec

17

17

17

17

17

17

k

Musket

23

19

23

19

23

19

 

Bless

31

23

31

23

31

23

 

Lighter

23

19

23

19

23

19

  1. Rows labeled k show the k-mer sizes selected for each tool and dataset.